Minggu, 30 Mei 2010
The 1st SODE 2010 after glow
Finally The 1st SODE 2010 (SMAN 2 Surabaya Open Debate event) that is organized by OSIS of SMAN 2 Sby and SMADA IDEA (SMADA Intellectual Debate Education Association) has finished. On behalf on the committee, we would like to congratulate, the winners of SODE 2010:
1st Winner RED WINE (Mytha SMAN 3 Sda, Rifan ITB, Citra SMAN 2 Sby)
2nd Winner UWIKA B
3rd Winner UMM A
4th Position SMPN 1 Ponorogo
(The 1st history in the national debate (if I am not mistaken), where a Junior high school team can break into final round..!!)
Best Speakers Categories:
Best of the best: Riphan (ITB)
University : Riphan (ITB)
Senior High School: David (Spider/SMAN 1 Krian)
Junior High School: Whanegi (SMPN 1 Ponorogo)
We would like to deliver our greatest gratitude to the A team (Mz Rizal-UNESA, Aini-ITS, Harist-POLINEMA, Rimba-UNAIR) and all of the Adjudicators for all of the friendly cooperation and the enormous assistance to the Committee. Our deepest gratitude also goes for all of Debaters for participating in SODE 2010.
We would like also to deliver our humblest and deepest apology for all of the lack and and the limitation of our ability in providing a satisfying service that might likely far from the definition of perfect.
Hopefully next year, SMADA IDEA could hold a better SODE with a better service and facilities for the debaters and the adjudicators.
It is our deepest expectation that the result of this SODE, could trigger the birth of more SMP debaters under the coaching of either SMA or Varsity debaters. If Ponorogo can do it, why can't we? right? MUST DO WE (mas Dwi)? :)
So in the end, it is expected that in the future we could provide a more number of high quality SMA and Varsity debaters for the selection of ISDC (SMA) and NUEDC (Varsity).
At the of the day, even though SODE has already finished,
but please DO keep it in your memory that...
Debate is a WAR but your weapons are WORDS
Thank you..
Regards
SODE 2010 COMMITTEE
Attachments:
The 1st SODE 2010 Tabulation:
http://www.ziddu.com/download/10071459/TABULATIONSODEFINAL.xls.html
The memory of SODE 2010 (Video & pictures):
http://www.ziddu.com/download/10074709/TheMemoryofSODE2010.wmv.html
1st Winner RED WINE (Mytha SMAN 3 Sda, Rifan ITB, Citra SMAN 2 Sby)
2nd Winner UWIKA B
3rd Winner UMM A
4th Position SMPN 1 Ponorogo
(The 1st history in the national debate (if I am not mistaken), where a Junior high school team can break into final round..!!)
Best Speakers Categories:
Best of the best: Riphan (ITB)
University : Riphan (ITB)
Senior High School: David (Spider/SMAN 1 Krian)
Junior High School: Whanegi (SMPN 1 Ponorogo)
We would like to deliver our greatest gratitude to the A team (Mz Rizal-UNESA, Aini-ITS, Harist-POLINEMA, Rimba-UNAIR) and all of the Adjudicators for all of the friendly cooperation and the enormous assistance to the Committee. Our deepest gratitude also goes for all of Debaters for participating in SODE 2010.
We would like also to deliver our humblest and deepest apology for all of the lack and and the limitation of our ability in providing a satisfying service that might likely far from the definition of perfect.
Hopefully next year, SMADA IDEA could hold a better SODE with a better service and facilities for the debaters and the adjudicators.
It is our deepest expectation that the result of this SODE, could trigger the birth of more SMP debaters under the coaching of either SMA or Varsity debaters. If Ponorogo can do it, why can't we? right? MUST DO WE (mas Dwi)? :)
So in the end, it is expected that in the future we could provide a more number of high quality SMA and Varsity debaters for the selection of ISDC (SMA) and NUEDC (Varsity).
At the of the day, even though SODE has already finished,
but please DO keep it in your memory that...
Debate is a WAR but your weapons are WORDS
Thank you..
Regards
SODE 2010 COMMITTEE
Attachments:
The 1st SODE 2010 Tabulation:
http://www.ziddu.com/download/10071459/TABULATIONSODEFINAL.xls.html
The memory of SODE 2010 (Video & pictures):
http://www.ziddu.com/download/10074709/TheMemoryofSODE2010.wmv.html
Langgan: Entri (Atom)
Selasa, 25 Mei 2010
TEAM CAP of SODE 2010 HAS BEEN FULFILLED
TEAM CAP (30 TEAMS)
SMP (4 TEAMS)
1. SMPN 1 Ponorogo
2. SMPN 1 Jetis Ponorogo
3. SMPN 2 Bojonegoro
4. SMP Muhammadiyah 5 Surabaya
SMA (10 TEAMS)
5. SMAK St Yusuf Malang
6. SMAN 2 Surabaya
7. SMKN 5 Surabaya A
8. SMKN 5 Surabaya B
9. SMAN 3 Sidoarjo
10. SMKN 4 Surabaya
11. SMAN 9 Surabaya
12. SMA Khadijah Surabaya A
13. SMA Khadijah Surabaya B
14. SMK 6 Surabaya
UNIVERSITY (11 TEAMS)
15. UNESA A
16. UNESA B
17. UNESA C
18. UWIKA A
19. UWIKA B
20. UM A
21. UM B
22. UMM A
23. UMM B
24. STIKOM A
25. STIKOM B
COALITION (5 TEAMS)
26. HAZZEL NUTT (Yulia UNAIR, Idho UNAIR, Emma UNAIR)
27. ICY CONE (Yuliana UNAIR, Hendra UNAIR, Yesinda UNAIR)
28. SPIDER (Choi UNESA, David SMAN 1 Krian, Firman SMAN 1 Krian)
29. RED WINE (Rivan ITB, Citra SMAN 2 Sby, Mytha SMAN 3 Sda)
30. PROPANE (Mr.X SMAN 1 Sda, Mr.Y SMAN 1 Sda, Mr.Z SMAN 3 Sda)
SMP (4 TEAMS)
1. SMPN 1 Ponorogo
2. SMPN 1 Jetis Ponorogo
3. SMPN 2 Bojonegoro
4. SMP Muhammadiyah 5 Surabaya
SMA (10 TEAMS)
5. SMAK St Yusuf Malang
6. SMAN 2 Surabaya
7. SMKN 5 Surabaya A
8. SMKN 5 Surabaya B
9. SMAN 3 Sidoarjo
10. SMKN 4 Surabaya
11. SMAN 9 Surabaya
12. SMA Khadijah Surabaya A
13. SMA Khadijah Surabaya B
14. SMK 6 Surabaya
UNIVERSITY (11 TEAMS)
15. UNESA A
16. UNESA B
17. UNESA C
18. UWIKA A
19. UWIKA B
20. UM A
21. UM B
22. UMM A
23. UMM B
24. STIKOM A
25. STIKOM B
COALITION (5 TEAMS)
26. HAZZEL NUTT (Yulia UNAIR, Idho UNAIR, Emma UNAIR)
27. ICY CONE (Yuliana UNAIR, Hendra UNAIR, Yesinda UNAIR)
28. SPIDER (Choi UNESA, David SMAN 1 Krian, Firman SMAN 1 Krian)
29. RED WINE (Rivan ITB, Citra SMAN 2 Sby, Mytha SMAN 3 Sda)
30. PROPANE (Mr.X SMAN 1 Sda, Mr.Y SMAN 1 Sda, Mr.Z SMAN 3 Sda)
Sabtu, 22 Mei 2010
WORDS FROM THE COMMITTEE
The cap of the 1st SODE 2010 has been fulfilled, thank you for the teams who have been registered, we will upload the list of the teams soon.
Regarding to the motions, all of the motions in SODE, either prepared or impromptu are designed to meet the qualification of philosophical debate, in which even though the proposal mechanism or practicality analysis sometimes needed but please do not consider that as your team's main tools to gain upperhand position in debate, it is fundementally okay to employ proposal mechanism or practicality analysis but we highly expected that the main course of the debate will go in the philosophical level. For beginner debaters, you might want to look up on the idea of Social Contract in wikipedia or google to help you broaden and develop your argument deeper into philosophical level.
So.., for the debaters, please prepare your WORDS for the upcoming WAR in SODE,
'coz in SODE, we believe that
Regarding to the motions, all of the motions in SODE, either prepared or impromptu are designed to meet the qualification of philosophical debate, in which even though the proposal mechanism or practicality analysis sometimes needed but please do not consider that as your team's main tools to gain upperhand position in debate, it is fundementally okay to employ proposal mechanism or practicality analysis but we highly expected that the main course of the debate will go in the philosophical level. For beginner debaters, you might want to look up on the idea of Social Contract in wikipedia or google to help you broaden and develop your argument deeper into philosophical level.
So.., for the debaters, please prepare your WORDS for the upcoming WAR in SODE,
'coz in SODE, we believe that
DEBATE IS A WAR, BUT YOUR WEAPONS ARE WORDS
Kamis, 13 Mei 2010
MOTION OF SODE 2010
PREPARED
THW justify violence to uphold democracy
THBT leaving euro is catastrophic
THW give national treasures back to its people
GRAND FINAL
THBT public pressure should not become a factor in deactivating any government official
HEADINGS FOR IMPROMPTU
(the option of the motions preference will be given from some of these headings)
-Sex and gender
-Right of equality
-Government
-Culture, religion and the right of self determination
-National
Regards
A-TEAM
THW justify violence to uphold democracy
THBT leaving euro is catastrophic
THW give national treasures back to its people
GRAND FINAL
THBT public pressure should not become a factor in deactivating any government official
HEADINGS FOR IMPROMPTU
(the option of the motions preference will be given from some of these headings)
-Sex and gender
-Right of equality
-Government
-Culture, religion and the right of self determination
-National
Regards
A-TEAM
Selasa, 27 April 2010
SODE 2010 (SMADA OPEN DEBATE EVENT)
But despite the fact that there are so many competitions, there are in fact only few Open Debate Tournament that has been held in
Now, to continue the spirit of the previous SEDOT Competition, where High School debaters and Varsity Debaters can compete each other. Hence, SMAN 2 Surabaya is proudly presenting to you,… (drum role) … SODE (SMADA Open Debate Event) 2010.
With several considerations, the Rules and Regulation of SODE 2010 would be a little bit different to the previous SEDOT 2009.
- Competition:
29 May - 30 May 2010
- Technical Meeting and Adjudicators Accreditation:
21 May 2010 (After Jumatan, 13.00 WIB)
SMAN 2
Jl. Wijayakusuma No.48
CONTESTANT LIMITATION:
- Contestants:
Junior High School students,
Senior High School students,
University students (Maximum 21 years old)
(proven by ID Card)
- Adjudicator accreditation (no age and institution limitation):
all of accredited adjudicators will get a certificate after the competition.
IDR 120.000,- / Team
(You have 2 kinds of option of team to join this Open Tournament)
1) Team from the same institution (Institutional team):
- Each institution may send up to 3 teams
in which the 3rd team will be placed in the waiting list (waiting list is sorted by date of registration). If the registration has been closed and the cap limit is not exceeded yet, these waiting list teams could join the competition, if not, the registration fee will be refunded.
- Each team may consist of some debaters from different institution
(ex: 1st speaker from UNAIR, 2nd Speaker from SMAN 1 Sidoarjo, 3rd Speaker from SMP 1 Surabaya) or (1st speaker from UM, 2nd speaker from SMAK St Albertus Malang, and 3rd speaker from SMAN 2 Surabaya)
All you need is just to creatively use your wildest imagination on how to create a solid team that consist of some killer speakers, so call those people, and persuade them to make a team with you, happy lobbying :)
- This kind of team is considered as a team that is representing each individual in that team, and will not be considered as a team that is representing any institution.
- Since it is not an institutional team, then this kind of team, should make a name for the team, all kind of name is free to be used (not a vulgar one we hope), you can come up with any name, as crazy as you can think.
(ex: Three virgins from hell, Triple Trouble, Happy three friends, Trio Kwek-Kwek, Ker-I-Nget (Keren dan Imyut b4Ng3t) or even Trio Macan
3) Of course, you might want to consult and ask permission to your coach, on whether or not you are allowed to make your own team, or you have to join the team from your institution.
- Different to the previous SEDOT 2009 which was using 6 Preliminary rounds, rank them up and decide the
winners.
- It'd be using Asian Parliamentary System.
There will be only 3 prepared motions, meanwhile the rest of the motions are impromptu, it is purposed to see the real skill of the team. For in the first place, it is supposed to be the battle between debaters and not the battle between coaches (who usually helped you preparing the motions).
Open: 1 May 2010
Closed: 21 May 2010
or until the cap of 30 team is reached, whichever happen first.
- You may come to SMAN 2 Surabaya (please contact the CP first)
- or you may transfer the registration fee to this bank account:
No : 142-00-0743712-1
a.n. NADHIFA MAULIDA
Bank Mandiri
(Please DO CONFIRM to the CP after the registration fee has been transferred, so that your team can be confirmed as a team that has already registered)
Limited to only 30 Teams
(First come/registered, first served)
- Only team that has paid / transferred the registration fee that would be considered registered and would be
prioritized to be registered.
- Booking without paying the registration fee would not be considered / prioritized to has been registered until the
registration money is paid.
- Registration:
Piala (085730084477)
- Confirmation of payment :
Nadhifa (03191728257)
- Info:
Citra (085730081932)
just click these two links:
-Formal Invitation -Rules and Registration Form
(CA:Rizal-UNESA; DCA:Aini-ITS, Haris-POLINEMA, Rimba-UNAIR)
DEBATE IS A WAR
BUT YOUR WEAPONS ARE WORDS
(Denzel Washington in “The Great Debaters”)
p.s:
for all Junior high school debaters, since this competition would be your first debate competition, thus we from smada idea debaters would be happy to help you to understand more about debate, you may come to SMAN 2 Surabaya, every Saturday (08.00 until finish) to join our weekly debate practice. It is our obligation to help beginner debaters (of Junior high school) like you to help you prepare yourself for this Open Debate Event.
BUT YOUR WEAPONS ARE WORDS
(Denzel Washington in “The Great Debaters”)
p.s:
