(Debate argument is not necessarily has to be like this, but some looks like this. In fact, the nature of debate itself is very dynamic, different team could come up with different or better idea, thus it is very recommended to not consider this argument as the best argument, instead, to be a better debater, you have to believe that actually you can simply make argument that so much better than this example argument)
1st GOVERNMENT/Affirmative/Positive (7.20 minutes)
Opening
A father of a paralyzed 5 years old little girl who was standing in the line of thousands of people in front of Ponari’s house was being interviewed by the reporter of one of Indonesia private television stations. He was being asked about his reason of joining this crowd. With a very simple mix of Bahasa and Javanese language, he said that he doesn’t have enough money to give his little daughter a very expensive medicine in the hospital to cure the bone cancer that has made his little daughter paralyzed. This is so sad but true, but this is the fact that exist in our society. That actually there is still so many poor people living in this country, especially in the villages. This poor people do not have enough money to go to the hospital to buy a very expensive medicine for a heavy disease that is not covered by askin for gakin. That’s why when Ponari’s mystical medical activity offering a medical recovery just by paying Rp. 1000/patient, these poor people willing to come all the way to Ponari’s house in Jombang just to have themselves cured by Ponari. Because not only very cheap, Ponari’s mystical medical activity also offering a full recovery even for some diseases that even some doctors raise their hand when being asked to cure the disease. This opening of Ponari’s mystical medical activity will surely help a lot of poor people who do not have enough money to go to the hospital to buy a very expensive medicine for a heavy disease that is not covered by askin for gakin.
Theme line
This is our theme line, this is our main reason and our urgency of proposing this Ponari’s activity to still being opened. Which is to help a lot of poor people who have been very hopeless because do not have enough money to go to the hospital to buy a very expensive medicine for a heavy disease that is not covered by askin for gakin.
Parameter
And to serve the need of Ponari to still have a proper education, so we are giving the parameter/limitation of our proposal here, by saying that the service of Ponari’s mystical medical activity is only conducted after Ponari get back from his school.
Team Split
First Speaker:
I as the first speaker will talk about The detail analysis about the nature of the recent condition that make it so urgent to implement our solution mechanism which is to still open Ponari’s mystical medical activity and the detail mechanism on how to implement this solution will be delivered by me as the first speaker.
Second Speaker:
While my second speaker will give a more detail analysis on some aspects of life in the recent condition that makes it feasible for our solution mechanism to be conducted. And my second speaker will also give some negative future implications that could be happen if our solution mechanism wasn’t conducted.
Third speaker:
And my third speaker will give some rebuttal and rebuild our case.
Reply speaker:
And the reply speech will be delivered by me.
The Nature and the urgency (of why we should still open Ponari’s mystical medical activity)
1st GOVERNMENT/Affirmative/Positive (7.20 minutes)
Opening
A father of a paralyzed 5 years old little girl who was standing in the line of thousands of people in front of Ponari’s house was being interviewed by the reporter of one of Indonesia private television stations. He was being asked about his reason of joining this crowd. With a very simple mix of Bahasa and Javanese language, he said that he doesn’t have enough money to give his little daughter a very expensive medicine in the hospital to cure the bone cancer that has made his little daughter paralyzed. This is so sad but true, but this is the fact that exist in our society. That actually there is still so many poor people living in this country, especially in the villages. This poor people do not have enough money to go to the hospital to buy a very expensive medicine for a heavy disease that is not covered by askin for gakin. That’s why when Ponari’s mystical medical activity offering a medical recovery just by paying Rp. 1000/patient, these poor people willing to come all the way to Ponari’s house in Jombang just to have themselves cured by Ponari. Because not only very cheap, Ponari’s mystical medical activity also offering a full recovery even for some diseases that even some doctors raise their hand when being asked to cure the disease. This opening of Ponari’s mystical medical activity will surely help a lot of poor people who do not have enough money to go to the hospital to buy a very expensive medicine for a heavy disease that is not covered by askin for gakin.
Theme line
This is our theme line, this is our main reason and our urgency of proposing this Ponari’s activity to still being opened. Which is to help a lot of poor people who have been very hopeless because do not have enough money to go to the hospital to buy a very expensive medicine for a heavy disease that is not covered by askin for gakin.
Parameter
And to serve the need of Ponari to still have a proper education, so we are giving the parameter/limitation of our proposal here, by saying that the service of Ponari’s mystical medical activity is only conducted after Ponari get back from his school.
Team Split
First Speaker:
I as the first speaker will talk about The detail analysis about the nature of the recent condition that make it so urgent to implement our solution mechanism which is to still open Ponari’s mystical medical activity and the detail mechanism on how to implement this solution will be delivered by me as the first speaker.
Second Speaker:
While my second speaker will give a more detail analysis on some aspects of life in the recent condition that makes it feasible for our solution mechanism to be conducted. And my second speaker will also give some negative future implications that could be happen if our solution mechanism wasn’t conducted.
Third speaker:
And my third speaker will give some rebuttal and rebuild our case.
Reply speaker:
And the reply speech will be delivered by me.
The Nature and the urgency (of why we should still open Ponari’s mystical medical activity)
Now, ladies and gentlemen, let's talk about the nature of the recent condition that make it so urgent to implement our solution mechanism which is to still open Ponari’s mystical medical activity.
I'm going to analyze this nature and urgency from 2 points of argument:
1st) from the point of, that only generic medicine that is covered by askin, and it makes poor people do not have any access to get expensive medicine that is not covered by askin. and
2nd) from the point of, that the lack of financial ability makes poor people see ponari as the best solution
Now let's analize the first point, which is:
1st point) Only generic medicine that is covered by askin, it makes poor people do not have any access to get expensive medicine that is not covered by askin
Ladies and gentlemen. It is so sad, that lately, every time we watches the news on TV, we see the picture of thousands of people, man, women, young, old, standing in the line of 5 kilometers long for hours or even for some couple of days just to get their disease being cured by Ponari’s mystical medical ability. Generally these patients of Ponari can be classified as those who do not have enough money to buy a very expensive medicine in the hospital for a heavy disease that is not covered by askin for gakin. This type of patients are the most desperate patients who do not have any idea no more on how to get their disease cured. The existence of this type of Ponari’s patient is surely not come up suddenly out of no where. They are the type of patient who is made by the accumulation of situation and condition of medical service in this country. The situation and condition of medical service that is so not friendly to poor people. Let’s analyze this from the aspect of medical fee, ladies and gentlemen it is something that can’t be denied, that poor people can’t have a good medicine in the hospital, especially on a heavy and a serious disease that needs a lot of money to buy the medicine, because we all know that askin for gakin only covers some regular medicines for some regular diseases, but askin for gakin not covers the price of medicine for some heavy disease like cancer that is very expensive.
this is exactly why I will also analize the second point, which is about:
2nd point) The lack of financial ability makes poor people see ponari as the best solution
This is the main reason of why poor people do not or even can not go to the hospital to buy the medicine that they need for their heavy disease. Because the medical fee of the hospital is so not friendly to the poor people.
Now since the opening of Ponari’s mystical medical activity, these poor people finally able to have their disease being cured with a very cheap medical fee, which is only Rp. 1000/patient. They finally do not have to suffer more just because they do not have enough money to buy a very expensive medicine in the hospital for a heavy disease that is not covered by askin for gakin.
Now ladies and gentlemen, based on all of those nature and urgency analysis, thus we are proposing to apply this solution mechanism.
Solution mechanism (on how to conduct Ponari’s mystical medical activity)
Ladies and gentlemen, of course in proposing this mechanism, we do not want to sacrifice the education of Ponari and the need of Ponari to play with his friends. That’s why in our solution mechanism, we are proposing Ponari to give his medical service only after he gets back from his school, which is from 3 pm to 5 pm. With this schedule we believe he will still have enough time to take a rest, or to do his homework, or to play with his friends. And not only managing the schedule, we are also proposing to build a big water tank in which Ponari will just have to put his mystical stone into the water and the water will be delivered by many long pipes to some places in Ponari’s village, so that many people will not have to get in a very long line along the street to Ponari’s house just to get their water touched by Ponari’s mystical stone. They also will not have to crowding in one place like in front of Ponari’s house, because by making many long pipes to several places in Ponari’s villages, people will have many option of places in which they can choose to get the water that has been touched by Ponari’s mystical stone. The management and the treatment of the water distribution by water tank and many long pipes itself will be managed by the villagers and should be supervised by the police authorities. We believe that by doing this mechanism, it will make it easy for people to get water from Ponari and it will also ensure the safety of people who come to get water from Ponari.
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to propose.
Now since the opening of Ponari’s mystical medical activity, these poor people finally able to have their disease being cured with a very cheap medical fee, which is only Rp. 1000/patient. They finally do not have to suffer more just because they do not have enough money to buy a very expensive medicine in the hospital for a heavy disease that is not covered by askin for gakin.
Now ladies and gentlemen, based on all of those nature and urgency analysis, thus we are proposing to apply this solution mechanism.
Solution mechanism (on how to conduct Ponari’s mystical medical activity)
Ladies and gentlemen, of course in proposing this mechanism, we do not want to sacrifice the education of Ponari and the need of Ponari to play with his friends. That’s why in our solution mechanism, we are proposing Ponari to give his medical service only after he gets back from his school, which is from 3 pm to 5 pm. With this schedule we believe he will still have enough time to take a rest, or to do his homework, or to play with his friends. And not only managing the schedule, we are also proposing to build a big water tank in which Ponari will just have to put his mystical stone into the water and the water will be delivered by many long pipes to some places in Ponari’s village, so that many people will not have to get in a very long line along the street to Ponari’s house just to get their water touched by Ponari’s mystical stone. They also will not have to crowding in one place like in front of Ponari’s house, because by making many long pipes to several places in Ponari’s villages, people will have many option of places in which they can choose to get the water that has been touched by Ponari’s mystical stone. The management and the treatment of the water distribution by water tank and many long pipes itself will be managed by the villagers and should be supervised by the police authorities. We believe that by doing this mechanism, it will make it easy for people to get water from Ponari and it will also ensure the safety of people who come to get water from Ponari.
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to propose.
1st NEGATIVE/Opposition (7.20 minutes)
Opening
Just because want themselves to be cured by ponari. 4 people have been killed because of exhausting, because of have to stands in the line for hours. And many more people injured. Enough is enough. It is so ironic, instead of get themselves being cured, this people get themselves getting killed.
Theme line
Ladies and gentlemen, as the Opposition side of the house, we would like to emphasize that we strongly reject the solution mechanism proposal of the Government side of the house because we believe that their proposal will only brings more harm than good for our society.
Team split
First speaker:
Related to this, I as the first speaker of the negative side of the house will talk about the nature of this motion that makes it so urgent for us to close this mystical medical activity that conducted by Ponari and I will also give an alternative solution mechanism to deal with this issue.
Second speaker:
Meanwhile my second speaker will talk about the feasibility and the future implication of this alternative solution mechanism
Third speaker:
My third speaker will give some rebuttal and rebuild our case
Reply speaker:
And the reply speech will be delivered by my second speaker
Rebuttal
Now. Before I give my elaboration about this case. Let’s analyze the argument that has been delivered by the first speaker of the government side of the house.
Ladies and gentlemen, as the Opposition side of the house, we would like to emphasize that we strongly reject the solution mechanism proposal of the Government side of the house because we believe that their proposal will only brings more harm than good for our society.
Team split
First speaker:
Related to this, I as the first speaker of the negative side of the house will talk about the nature of this motion that makes it so urgent for us to close this mystical medical activity that conducted by Ponari and I will also give an alternative solution mechanism to deal with this issue.
Second speaker:
Meanwhile my second speaker will talk about the feasibility and the future implication of this alternative solution mechanism
Third speaker:
My third speaker will give some rebuttal and rebuild our case
Reply speaker:
And the reply speech will be delivered by my second speaker
Rebuttal
Now. Before I give my elaboration about this case. Let’s analyze the argument that has been delivered by the first speaker of the government side of the house.
I have 3 points of rebuttal:
1st) that only generic medicine that is covered by askin, and it makes poor people do not have any access to get expensive medicine that is not covered by askin
2nd) from the point of, that the lack of financial ability makes poor people see ponari as the best solution
3rd) from the point of the feasibility of their solution mechanism
let's analize their 1st point, which is about:
1st) that only generic medicine that is covered by askin, and it makes poor people do not have any access to get expensive medicine that is not covered by askin.
Ladies and gentlemen, it seems the goverment side of the house has been terribly miss informed about the mechanism of askin, they seem to believe that poor people who do not have askin are not able to have access to get expensive medicine to cure their serious illness, well ladies and gentlemen, this statement is so totally wrong, because in fact, poor people are still able to have access to expensive medicine, this shows that actually the government of indonesia cares about its people, especially the poor people, so if the government side of the house has a different believe to this fact, it only indicate their lack of information about this issue.
2nd) from the point of, that the lack of financial ability makes poor people see ponari as the best solution. ladies and gentlemen, it has been widely known that indonesian people have high curiousity about something that has something to do with mystic. The ponari phenomenon is also included in this criteria. After hearing and see about ponari from the news in the television, people are getting more curious, the want to know more about ponari and want to proof it with their own eyes that ponari is really that good in healing one's disease. That is actually the fundamental reason of those people in visiting ponari. as you can see now, the visitor of ponari is not as many as it is before. It shows that the booming of ponari's visitor earlier is only temporarily and only to fullfil people's curiosity. So if the goverment side of the house said that the lack of financial ability makes poor people see ponari as the best solution, it'd be so wrong
3rd) from the point of the feasibility of their solution mechanism.
3rd) from the point of the feasibility of their solution mechanism.
the gov side of the house was proposing to still open the activity of ponari by saying that ponari will only heal the patient after he getting back from school and ponari will only plunge his magical stone into a big water tank, in which the water from the tank will be carried by long pipe to several places around ponari's house so the visitors won't have to stand in the long line to get it. Ladies and gentlemen, let's analize whether or not their solution mechanism is feasible to be conducted. 1st from the the idea that ponari will only heal people after he getting back from school, ladies and gentlemen, this idea itself has shown that actualy ponari is being used by people around him just to get financial benefit, this people around him, his family or hs close relative, do not really care about the childhood of ponari, because from the idea that is said by the gov side of the house we can see that the gov side of the house is suggesting that ponari won't be able to enjoy his childhood, he won't be able to play with his friends after getting back from school and second won't be able to do his homework after school, it will slowly makes the education of ponari becomes worse than before. and now, let's analize their solution mechanism, which is by plunging ponari's magical stone into a big water tank, in which the water from the tank will be carried by long pipe to several places around ponari's house so the visitors won't have to stand in the long line to get it. Well, ladies and getlemen, the research team from government hospital has conducted a research on the sample of ponari's stone, and it shows that the stone, like any other ordinary stones, is not good for man's health and it is also not hygiene, so why would risk your life on something that is not certain like ponari's stone, ladies and gentlemen, the healing effect is actualy only because of those people believe, they believe that they can be cured by ponari's stone, that's why they are being cured, but it only works if you really really has a big believe on ponari's stone, a 100% percent believe, or in other way saying t, it means it only works for some small number of people, because not all people has this strong believe. If believe is the only thing that you need in here, then why not go to the psychiatrists? they are more expert in making people believe in themselves, they very good in giving motivation to people. So ladies and gentlemen, no matter how good the mechanism of solution that is proposed by the gov side of the house, the logic is simple, that the ponari's stone is actually no different to any other ordinary stone the only thing that makes it different is only your believe, but then again, why risk your health on this not hygiene stone, if the result is unpredictable, why just not go to the hospital? it is healthier and more accesible, you can access hospital everywhere in your own town, you don't have to waste your energy, time and money just to go all the way to Jombang, just to see ponari, that is so not efficient and ineffective.
This is also why in our team argument, we are going to analize more about the things that makes it so urgent for us to not go to ponari
The Nature and the urgency (of why we should close Ponari’s mystical medical activity)
Ladies and gentlemen. There are so many reasons of why it is so urgent for us to close Ponari’s mystical medical activity.
Security aspect
From the security aspect we can see that there's no any responsibility at all from ponari's side on the death of several old people who died because of tired standing in the long line just to see ponari to have their illness getting cured, it is so ironic, because what they get is getting killed because of tired standing in the long line. the other security aspect is from the health security responsibility, there's neither ponari's side responsibility on the worsen health effect after drinking water from ponari. at least hospital has health insurance, how about ponari? of course not, he doesn't even care about those people insurance.
Health aspect
From the Health aspect we can see that the stone that is being used by ponari is not hygiene and can cause another stomach disease, there's not any guarantee that it can cure your disease. so why risk your health or your life over something uncertain like that
Social aspect
From the Social aspect we can see that the ponari's activity is actually disturbing the activity of people in the ponari's village, the farmers can not go to their field because there are too many people blocking the way, moreover it also raise internal conflict in the ponar's family.
Education aspect
From the Education aspect we can see that it disturb the education process of ponari, ponari can do his homework or study after school, because he has to heal so many people everyday after school, this is so not good for the future of ponari education.
Psychological aspect
From the Psychological aspect we can see that as a child, ponari needs to play with his friends, but how he can play if everyday he has to heal so many patient, this kind of activity will surely steal ponari's childhood
Ladies and gentlemen. There are so many reasons of why it is so urgent for us to close Ponari’s mystical medical activity.
Security aspect
From the security aspect we can see that there's no any responsibility at all from ponari's side on the death of several old people who died because of tired standing in the long line just to see ponari to have their illness getting cured, it is so ironic, because what they get is getting killed because of tired standing in the long line. the other security aspect is from the health security responsibility, there's neither ponari's side responsibility on the worsen health effect after drinking water from ponari. at least hospital has health insurance, how about ponari? of course not, he doesn't even care about those people insurance.
Health aspect
From the Health aspect we can see that the stone that is being used by ponari is not hygiene and can cause another stomach disease, there's not any guarantee that it can cure your disease. so why risk your health or your life over something uncertain like that
Social aspect
From the Social aspect we can see that the ponari's activity is actually disturbing the activity of people in the ponari's village, the farmers can not go to their field because there are too many people blocking the way, moreover it also raise internal conflict in the ponar's family.
Education aspect
From the Education aspect we can see that it disturb the education process of ponari, ponari can do his homework or study after school, because he has to heal so many people everyday after school, this is so not good for the future of ponari education.
Psychological aspect
From the Psychological aspect we can see that as a child, ponari needs to play with his friends, but how he can play if everyday he has to heal so many patient, this kind of activity will surely steal ponari's childhood
so how we are going to deal with this issue? we are proposing an alternative solution that we believe is better that the solution that has been proposed by the gov side of the house:
Alternative solution mechanism (on how to deal with this issue)
(Example: by universal health care)
We aware that the phenomenon that’s happening in Jombang is actually because of the lack of medical service support to poor people, we also aware that askin for gakin only covers regular medicine for regular disease and not covers expensive medicine for heavy disease. That’s why we are proposing a better alternative solution to deal with this issue.
Ladies and gentlemen. To deal with medical treatment issue in this motion. We are proposing to apply universal health care system in Indonesia. Universal health care system is a system in which all of the citizen of Indonesia, either rich or poor, will be given the same medical treatment and medicine by all of public hospitals in Indonesia, and all of the medical treatment and the medicine will be totally free, everybody can enjoy the same medical treatment and have a better quality of medicine without have to worry about the expensive fee of medicine. The universal health care system is a system in which rich people and workers with salary above Rp. 2 millions are obligated to pay maximally 10% of their salary for health care tax every month, in which all of the money will be used to provide and develop all of medical equipment and hospital facilities in every public hospital in Indonesia, the money can also be used to supply all the medicines needed for all diseases. This system is encouraging a better social understanding and care to each other, because even though workers whose salary is under Rp.2 million or even poor people who do not have any money at all, do not have or can not afford to pay the health care tax, but the money from the tax itself will be used for the betterment of all of health care system of all the citizen of Indonesia. We strongly believe that this universal health care system is a lot of better than Ponari’s mystical medical activity. Now the government side of the house should be able to convince all of us here Ponari’s mystical medical activity is better than the implementation of universal health care system, they should give a convincing explanation of why the implementation of universal health care is not good for the betterment of the health of people in Indonesia. Which of course we believe that they will find some hard time to find the reasonable explanation to oppose our alternative solution.
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to oppose.
(Example: by universal health care)
We aware that the phenomenon that’s happening in Jombang is actually because of the lack of medical service support to poor people, we also aware that askin for gakin only covers regular medicine for regular disease and not covers expensive medicine for heavy disease. That’s why we are proposing a better alternative solution to deal with this issue.
Ladies and gentlemen. To deal with medical treatment issue in this motion. We are proposing to apply universal health care system in Indonesia. Universal health care system is a system in which all of the citizen of Indonesia, either rich or poor, will be given the same medical treatment and medicine by all of public hospitals in Indonesia, and all of the medical treatment and the medicine will be totally free, everybody can enjoy the same medical treatment and have a better quality of medicine without have to worry about the expensive fee of medicine. The universal health care system is a system in which rich people and workers with salary above Rp. 2 millions are obligated to pay maximally 10% of their salary for health care tax every month, in which all of the money will be used to provide and develop all of medical equipment and hospital facilities in every public hospital in Indonesia, the money can also be used to supply all the medicines needed for all diseases. This system is encouraging a better social understanding and care to each other, because even though workers whose salary is under Rp.2 million or even poor people who do not have any money at all, do not have or can not afford to pay the health care tax, but the money from the tax itself will be used for the betterment of all of health care system of all the citizen of Indonesia. We strongly believe that this universal health care system is a lot of better than Ponari’s mystical medical activity. Now the government side of the house should be able to convince all of us here Ponari’s mystical medical activity is better than the implementation of universal health care system, they should give a convincing explanation of why the implementation of universal health care is not good for the betterment of the health of people in Indonesia. Which of course we believe that they will find some hard time to find the reasonable explanation to oppose our alternative solution.
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to oppose.
From the example of GOVERNMENT and NEGATIVE 1st speaker, you can now try to make your own argument for the 2nd speaker...,
2nd GOVERNMENT/Affirmative/Positive (7.20 minutes)
Rebuttal
(firstly, you should defend your team by answering all of the detail of argument that has been said by the 1st speaker of the opposition side of the house that purposed to attack your team argument)
2nd GOVERNMENT/Affirmative/Positive (7.20 minutes)
Rebuttal
(firstly, you should defend your team by answering all of the detail of argument that has been said by the 1st speaker of the opposition side of the house that purposed to attack your team argument)
Now. Before I give my elaboration about this case. Let’s analyze first the urgency and the solution mechanism that has been brought by the first speaker of the negative side of the house.
(Attack the feasibility of Opposition’s solution mechanism seeing from several aspects of life (example: security aspect, health aspect, social aspect, moral aspect, education aspect, psychological aspect, etc) in recent condition. Give some evidence and argument on why the Opposition’s solution mechanism is can not be conducted.)
Ladies and gentlemen. The first speaker of the negative side of the house said that the urgency of why Ponari should close this mystical medical activity is because that (bla..bla..bla..), and the first speaker of the negative side of the house also gave an alternative proposal on how to deal with medical issue in Indonesia is by (bla..bla..bla..). But ladies and gentlemen, their urgency is actually not that urgent if being compared with the harm that it can brings, which is, (bla..bla..bla..). Now, let’s see the feasibility of their solution mechanism, which is about the implementation of universal health care system in Indonesia, well, seeing from the aspect of (bla..bla..bla..) we can clearly see that their proposal is actually not possible to be conducted because (bla..bla..bla..). Secondly seeing from the aspect of (bla..bla..bla..) we can clearly see that their proposal is actually not possible to be conducted because (bla..bla..bla..). Thirdly (bla..bla..bla..). Now from all of these evidence, we can clearly see that their urgency is actually brings more harm than good for the society and also their proposal is actually not possible to be conducted.
Feasibility
Now let’s see the possibilities of our solution mechanism to be conducted, which is, to still open Ponari’s mystical medical activity, seeing from several aspects of life:
Security aspect
From the security aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Health aspect
From the Health aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Social aspect
From the Social aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Education aspect
From the Education aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Financial aspect
From the Financial aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Psychological aspect
From the Psychological aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Future implication
Now let’s analyze some negative future implications that could be happen if Ponari’s mystical medical activity should be closed:
Health aspect
From the health aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Economical aspect
From the economical aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Social aspect
From the Social aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Education aspect
From the Education aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Financial aspect
From the Financial aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Psychological aspect
From the Psychological aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to propose.
2nd NEGATIVE/Opposition (7.20 minutes)
Rebuttal
(firstly, you should defend your team by answering all of the detail of argument that has been said by the 1st and the 2nd speaker of the government side of the house that purposed to attack your team argument)
Now. Before I give my elaboration about this case. Let’s analyze first, the urgency and the solution mechanism that has been brought by the first speaker of the government side of the house. And second, the feasibility and the future implication of their solution mechanism that has been brought by the second speaker of the government side of the house
(Attack the feasibility of government’s solution mechanism seeing from several aspects of life (example: security aspect, health aspect, social aspect, moral aspect, education aspect, psychological aspect, etc) in recent condition. Give some evidence and argument on why the government’s solution mechanism is can not be conducted.)
Ladies and gentlemen. The second and the first speaker of the government side of the house said that the urgency of why Ponari should open this mystical medical activity is because that (bla..bla..bla..), and the second and the first speaker of the government side of the house also said that (bla..bla..bla..). But ladies and gentlemen, actually (bla..bla..bla..). Now, let’s see the feasibility of their solution mechanism, seeing from the aspect of (bla..bla..bla..) we can clearly see that their proposal is actually not possible to be conducted because (bla..bla..bla..). Secondly seeing from the aspect of (bla..bla..bla..) we can clearly see that their proposal is actually not possible to be conducted because (bla..bla..bla..). Thirdly (bla..bla..bla..). Now from all of these evidence, we can clearly see that their urgency is actually brings more harm than good for the society and also their proposal is actually not possible to be conducted.
Feasibility
Now let’s see the possibilities of our alternative solution mechanism to be conducted, which is, to implement the system of universal health care which we believe is way better than Ponari’s mystical medical activity, seeing from several aspects of life:
Security aspect
From the security aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Health aspect
From the Health aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Social aspect
From the Social aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Education aspect
From the Education aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Financial aspect
From the Financial aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Psychological aspect
From the Psychological aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Future implication
Negative future implication if Ponari’s mystical medical activity is still being opened:
Health aspect
From the health aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Economical aspect
From the economical aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Social aspect
From the Social aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Education aspect
From the Education aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Financial aspect
From the Financial aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
Psychological aspect
From the Psychological aspect we can see that (bla..bla..bla..).
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to oppose.
3rd GOVERNMENT/Affirmative/Positive (7.20 minutes)
Rebuttal
(firstly, you should defend your team more by answering all of the detail of argument that has been said by the 1st and the 2nd speaker of the negative side of the house that purposed to attack your team argument)
(secondly. More Attack the feasibility of negative’s solution mechanism seeing from several aspects of life (example: security aspect, health aspect, social aspect, moral aspect, education aspect, psychological aspect, etc) in recent condition. Give some more evidence and argument on why the negative’s solution mechanism is can not be conducted.)
Rebuild/summary
(give a short summary of the 1st and 2nd speaker of your team, to strengthen your team argument)
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to propose.
3rd NEGATIVE/Opposition (7.20 minutes)
Rebuttal
(firstly, you should defend your team more by answering all of the detail of argument that has been said by the 1st and the 2nd speaker of the government side of the house that purposed to attack your team argument)
(secondly. More Attack the feasibility of negative’s solution mechanism seeing from several aspects of life (example: security aspect, health aspect, social aspect, moral aspect, education aspect, psychological aspect, etc) in recent condition. Give some more evidence and argument on why the government’s solution mechanism is can not be conducted.)
Rebuild/summary
(give a short summary of the 1st and 2nd speaker of your team, to strengthen your team argument)
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to oppose.
NEGATIVE/Opposition Reply speech (4.20 minutes)
(give an unbalance comparison between the argument of negative team and the argument of the government team that shows that negative team’s argument is way better than the government’s team argument)
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to oppose.
GOVERNMENT/Affirmative/Positive Reply speech (4.20 minutes)
(give an unbalance comparison between the argument of government team and the argument of the opponent team that shows that government team’s argument is way better than the opponent’s team argument)
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to propose.
Rebuild/summary
(give a short summary of the 1st and 2nd speaker of your team, to strengthen your team argument)
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to oppose.
NEGATIVE/Opposition Reply speech (4.20 minutes)
(give an unbalance comparison between the argument of negative team and the argument of the government team that shows that negative team’s argument is way better than the government’s team argument)
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to oppose.
GOVERNMENT/Affirmative/Positive Reply speech (4.20 minutes)
(give an unbalance comparison between the argument of government team and the argument of the opponent team that shows that government team’s argument is way better than the opponent’s team argument)
conclusion
so based on all of those explanation, it shows that at the end of the day, our argument is better and stronger, and we beg you to propose.
0 komentar:
Poskan Komentar